Filipino Crab Mentality in America: When Community Turns Into Silent Competition | Fil-am Journey
Filipino Crab Mentality in America: When Community Turns Into Silent Competition
Examining identity, immigrant dynamics, research studies, and the psychological realities of community relations abroad.
When Being Filipino in America Does Not Always Feel Like an Automatic Connection
Moving to another country can be difficult.
For many Filipinos arriving in the United States, meeting another Filipino can feel comforting.
You may expect an immediate connection.
You may expect to speak the same language, understand similar jokes, share familiar food, and understand what it feels like to leave the Philippines and build a life somewhere new.
But sometimes, the experience can be more complicated.
Some newly arrived Filipinos may experience situations where they feel judged, compared, ignored, or treated differently by fellow Filipinos who have lived in America for many years.
Sometimes the difference appears in conversations about jobs, money, immigration status, education, where someone lives, or even English.
One question that can make a newcomer uncomfortable is:
Why are we speaking English to each other when we both know we are Filipino?
Of course, there is nothing wrong with speaking English.
Many Filipinos genuinely feel more comfortable speaking English, especially those who grew up in the United States or have spent many years here.
But sometimes, language may not be the real issue.
The issue may be the feeling behind the interaction.
Does someone speak English simply because that is what they are comfortable with?
Or does another person feel that English is being used to create distance, demonstrate superiority, or make someone else feel less educated or less successful?
These questions open a much larger conversation about identity, insecurity, social comparison, language, immigration, and what Filipinos commonly call crab mentality.
This article is not about saying that all Filipinos behave this way.
They do not.
Many Filipinos in America are generous, welcoming, supportive, and willing to help newcomers build a better life.
But difficult experiences can still exist within a community.
Talking honestly about them may help us understand each other better.
What Is Filipino Crab Mentality?
The expression crab mentality is commonly used to describe a situation in which people pull others down instead of supporting them.
The image comes from the idea of crabs inside a container. When one crab attempts to climb out, the others are said to pull it back down.
In everyday Filipino conversations, the term is often associated with behaviors such as:
- Jealousy
- Envy
- Excessive comparison
- Gossip
- Competition
- Criticizing another person's success
- Trying to make someone feel less successful
- Feeling uncomfortable when another person moves ahead
But there is an important distinction.
Crab mentality is not a scientifically established personality trait belonging to Filipinos.
There is no reliable national statistic showing that a certain percentage of Filipinos have crab mentality.
Instead, it is better understood as a cultural expression used to describe certain unhealthy behaviors.
Researchers studying Filipino Americans have examined related issues, including colonial mentality, internalized oppression, ethnic identity, social support, cultural identity, and discrimination.
These areas of research give us a much stronger foundation for understanding why comparison, identity, language, and social status can sometimes become complicated within Filipino communities.
What the Research Actually Shows
One of the most important studies related to this discussion was conducted by psychologists E. J. R. David and Sumie Okazaki.
In 2006, they developed and tested the Colonial Mentality Scale for Filipino Americans.
The study used an exploratory sample of 292 Filipino Americans and a confirmatory sample of 311 Filipino Americans.
The researchers identified colonial mentality as a multidimensional psychological construct with five related factors.
One of those factors was particularly relevant to the topic of this article:
Within-group discrimination.
The scale included experiences involving distinctions between newly arrived Filipino immigrants and Filipino Americans who were more Americanized.
The study examined attitudes involving newly arrived immigrants, accents, Americanization, and how some Filipinos viewed other Filipinos who were perceived as less Americanized.
The researchers concluded that colonial mentality was associated with psychological well-being and mental health among Filipino Americans.
This is important.
It does not prove that Filipino Americans have crab mentality.
But it demonstrates that researchers have identified and measured certain forms of negative attitudes toward Filipino identity and toward other Filipinos within Filipino American populations.
That makes the conversation more complicated—and more interesting—than simply calling someone jealous.
Another Study Looked at 219 Filipino American Immigrants
Researchers E. J. R. David and Kevin L. Nadal later examined the psychological experiences of Filipino American immigrants.
Their research included:
- 6 interviews
- 219 Filipino American immigrants in survey research
The researchers found evidence that Filipino American immigrants experienced ethnic and cultural denigration in both the Philippines and the United States.
Their findings suggested that experiences of ethnic and cultural denigration may contribute to the development of colonial mentality and that colonial mentality may have negative psychological consequences.
This gives us another way to understand the issue.
Sometimes negative attitudes toward another Filipino may not simply be about jealousy.
They may be connected to deeper ideas about:
- What it means to be successful
- What it means to be American
- What it means to be Filipino
- Which language is considered prestigious
- How people view accents
- How people perceive education
- How people perceive social status
These ideas can develop over many years.
A Study of 410 Filipino Americans
The research becomes even more interesting with a 2019 study by Victor E. Tuazon, Edith Gonzalez, Daniel Gutierrez, and Lauren Nelson.
The researchers studied 410 Filipino Americans.
They examined relationships among:
- Colonial mentality
- Ethnic identity
- Acculturation
- Social support
- Internalized oppression
- Mental-health help-seeking
The researchers found that colonial mentality was negatively related to ethnic identity development and social support.
They also found that higher levels of colonial mentality significantly predicted more negative attitudes toward seeking mental-health help, even after considering other variables.
Again, this does not prove that Filipino Americans have crab mentality.
But it provides evidence that attitudes surrounding Filipino identity can have real social and psychological consequences.
That is an important distinction.
Filipino Crab Mentality and Colonial Mentality Are Not the Same Thing
These two terms should not be used interchangeably.
Crab mentality usually refers to behavior such as:
- Pulling someone down
- Jealousy
- Excessive competition
- Gossip
- Resenting another person's success
Colonial mentality refers to internalized attitudes influenced by colonial history, including possible beliefs that things associated with the colonizing culture are superior while one's own culture or identity is inferior.
Researchers have specifically studied colonial mentality among Filipino Americans.
There can be overlap between the two ideas.
For example, if someone believes that being more Americanized makes a Filipino more respectable than a newly arrived immigrant, that attitude could involve questions of identity and internalized cultural hierarchy.
But that does not automatically mean the person has "crab mentality."
Keeping these concepts separate makes the discussion more accurate.
Important Disclaimer: This Does Not Represent All Filipinos
Before discussing this topic, one thing must be clear: not all Filipinos have a crab mentality.
This article does not claim that Filipino people, Filipino Americans, or Filipino healthcare workers generally behave this way. Many Filipinos genuinely support one another, mentor newcomers, share opportunities, and celebrate each other's success.
The experiences discussed in this article refer to a behavior that some people may encounter within certain Filipino communities or social circles. They should not be used to label an entire culture or group of people.
The term “crab mentality” is used here to describe situations involving unhealthy comparison, jealousy, competition, exclusion, or behavior that makes another person feel inferior. However, not every disagreement, personality difference, American accent, successful lifestyle, or difficult relationship should automatically be called crab mentality.
People who have lived in the United States for many years may naturally change the way they speak, communicate, or live. Having an American accent or speaking English fluently does not automatically mean that someone believes they are better than other Filipinos.
This article explores an issue that some people have personally experienced or observed. The purpose is not to attack Filipinos. The purpose is to encourage honest conversation about how Filipino communities can become more supportive, respectful, and united.
Filipino Americans by the Numbers
Understanding the Filipino American population also helps explain why experiences can be so different.
According to [Pew Research Center](https://www.pewresearch.org/)'s analysis of U.S. Census Bureau data, approximately 4.2 million Filipinos lived in the United States in the period covered by its recent analysis.
The Filipino American population includes people with very different backgrounds.
Some were born in the Philippines and immigrated to America.
Others were born in the United States.
Some arrived as adults. Others arrived as children.
Some speak Filipino languages at home. Others primarily speak English.
These differences matter.
English Proficiency Among Filipino Americans
[Pew Research Center](https://www.pewresearch.org/) reports that 85% of Filipinos ages 5 and older in the United States are English proficient.
But the difference between immigrants and U.S.-born Filipinos is particularly interesting:
| Group | English proficient |
|---|---|
| Filipino Americans overall | 85% |
| Filipino immigrants | 71% |
| U.S.-born Filipinos | 98% |
[Pew Research Center](https://www.pewresearch.org/) defines English proficiency as either speaking only English at home or, when another language is spoken at home, reporting that they speak English "very well."
This helps explain why language can be complicated within Filipino American communities.
A Filipino who recently arrived from the Philippines may have a different level of comfort with English than someone born and raised in the United States.
And even among immigrants, English ability varies greatly.
Therefore, speaking English does not automatically mean someone is pretending to be American or trying to appear superior.
For some Filipino Americans, English is simply their most comfortable language.
Filipino Languages Are Still Part of the Community
English is important, but Filipino languages remain an important part of Filipino American life.
[Pew Research Center](https://www.pewresearch.org/) reports that among Filipinos ages 5 and older:
- 43% speak Filipino or Tagalog at home
- 2% speak Ilocano
- 1% speak Cebuano
- 51% speak only English at home
These numbers demonstrate something important:
There is no single language experience among Filipino Americans.
A Filipino family from Manila may have a different language experience from a family from Cebu.
A family from Ilocos may have a different language experience from a family from Mindanao.
Some Filipino Americans speak Tagalog. Some speak Cebuano. Some speak Ilocano. Some speak another Philippine language. Some speak English almost exclusively.
And many move between several languages depending on who they are talking to.
So when two Filipinos speak English, we should not automatically assume that one person thinks they are better than the other.
Sometimes English is simply the language that works best for both people.
When Filipinos Meet Other Filipinos in America
Imagine someone who has recently arrived from the Philippines.
Everything may feel new.
They may be learning:
- How transportation works
- How American workplaces operate
- How health insurance works
- How schools operate
- How taxes work
- How to communicate in professional settings
- How to build a new social network
Then they meet someone from the Philippines who has already lived in America for many years.
Sometimes, that person becomes a guide.
They may help the newcomer find a job. They may explain how things work. They may introduce them to other people. They may help them understand American systems. They may simply listen.
That is the Filipino community at its best.
But sometimes the relationship can feel different.
The newcomer may feel as if they are being evaluated.
They may hear questions about:
- Their job
- Their salary
- Where they live
- Their car
- Their education
- Their immigration journey
- Their English
- Their accent
- How long they have lived in America
None of these questions are automatically negative.
The problem is often the way the questions are asked and what happens afterward.
A conversation can feel welcoming. Or it can feel like an interview.
The Silent Competition Nobody Talks About
Competition is not always obvious.
Nobody has to say:
"I am better than you."
Sometimes competition happens silently.
One person talks about their job. Another talks about their salary. Someone compares houses. Someone compares cars. Someone compares children's achievements. Someone compares immigration experiences. Someone compares how long they have lived in America. Someone compares how "American" another person has become.
This can create an uncomfortable environment within a community that should ideally feel supportive.
A newcomer may begin to wonder:
Do I need to become more successful before I am respected?
Do I need to speak better English?
Do I need a better job?
Do I need a nicer car?
Do I need to prove that moving to America was worth it?
These pressures do not necessarily come from one person.
Sometimes they come from society, family expectations, social media, or our own tendency to compare ourselves with others.
But when comparison becomes constant, relationships can suffer.
Why Do Some Filipinos Speak English to Other Filipinos?
This is one of the most interesting questions in Filipino American communities, but there is no single answer.
Some Filipinos speak English because they:
- Grew up in the United States
- Were educated primarily in English
- Work in English-speaking environments
- Feel more comfortable expressing certain ideas in English
- Have lived in America for many years
- Have children who primarily speak English
- Come from different regions of the Philippines
- Simply prefer English
The Philippines is linguistically diverse. Not every Filipino's first language is Tagalog.
There are many Philippine languages, including Cebuano, Ilocano, Hiligaynon, Waray and others.
Therefore, English can sometimes become the common language between Filipinos who have different linguistic backgrounds.
That is completely normal.
The problem begins only when language is intentionally used to embarrass, exclude, or diminish someone.
When English Starts to Feel Like a Status Symbol
In some situations, English can become associated with education, professional success, intelligence, social class, international experience, and being "more American."
This can create pressure. A Filipino with a strong accent may worry about being judged. A newcomer may feel embarrassed about making grammatical mistakes. Someone may remain quiet because they are afraid of being corrected, or even avoid speaking their own language.
But an accent does not determine intelligence. Grammar mistakes do not determine someone's worth. Speaking Cebuano, Tagalog, Ilocano, or another Philippine language does not make someone less educated.
Language is a skill. It is not a measurement of human value.
What Research Says About Filipino Identity
The issue of identity becomes even more interesting when we consider that Filipino Americans do not all describe themselves in the same way.
[Pew Research Center](https://www.pewresearch.org/) surveyed 1,051 Filipino American adults in 2022–2023.
Among those surveyed:
- 61% most often described themselves as "Filipino" or "Filipino American"
- 20% most often described themselves as "Asian American" or "Asian"
- 13% most often described themselves as "American"
[Pew Research Center](https://www.pewresearch.org/) also found that 16% said they had hidden some part of their heritage from people who are not Asian.
These numbers show how complicated identity can become across generations. A person born in Manila who immigrated to America at age 30 may have a very different experience from someone born in New York to Filipino parents. Both are Filipino, but their experiences may be completely different.
The Difference Between Adapting and Pretending
People change when they live in a new country. That is normal.
Someone who has lived in America for 10, 20, or 30 years may speak differently from someone who just arrived, and their children may have grown up in a completely different environment. That does not mean they have forgotten that they are Filipino, nor does being comfortable speaking English mean they are pretending to be American.
At the same time, newcomers can sometimes feel hurt when they believe another Filipino is intentionally distancing themselves from Filipino culture.
Instead of immediately assuming "That person thinks they are better because they speak English," we should consider other possibilities, while longtime Filipino Americans can also remember that newcomers may feel intimidated. A little patience can make a huge difference.
Research Has Even Identified Within-Group Discrimination
The 2006 Colonial Mentality Scale developed by David and Okazaki included a factor called within-group discrimination, examining attitudes involving Filipino Americans' perceptions of newly arrived Filipino immigrants, Americanization, accents, and cultural differences.
This demonstrates that researchers have investigated attitudes toward other Filipinos within the community. While not proof of a national "crab mentality," it shows tensions within the Filipino American community are a legitimate subject of psychological research.
Why Might This Competition Happen?
Several factors may contribute to unhealthy competition:
- Insecurity: Sometimes people criticize others because they are struggling with their own insecurities and question their own lives when seeing others succeed.
- Constant Comparison: Social media highlights vacations, new houses, cars, and promotions while hiding debt, stress, and sacrifices, creating frustration through comparison.
- Different Immigration Experiences: Arrivals through employment, family, studentship, or birth create varying paths that make it easy to judge without understanding.
- The Desire to Appear Successful: Moving abroad creates pressure to prove "I made it," turning success into something that must be displayed.
- Language and Identity: Language can be emotional; struggles with English or a native language can make people feel their identity is judged.
Colonial History and the Filipino American Experience
The Philippines has a long history of Spanish and American colonial influence. Researchers studying Filipino American psychology (such as Kevin Nadal, E. J. R. David, and Sumie Okazaki) have argued that colonial history can continue to influence ideas surrounding language, education, beauty, culture, social status, and identity.
This does not mean Filipinos are incapable of being proud of their culture; rather, history can leave complicated impressions influencing how people view themselves and each other.
The Good Side of the Filipino Community
Across America, Filipinos support each other through family networks, churches, community organizations, workplaces, professional groups, and businesses.
Many longtime immigrants help newcomers find housing, jobs, schools, and social connections, while working hard to preserve food, festivals, music, and traditions.
The Filipino community is not defined by crab mentality—many communities are built around helping one another, which is why negative competition can feel so disappointing when we know our community is capable of something better.
So What Is the Solution?
- 1. Stop Judging Someone's English: Do not assume someone is less intelligent because of an accent or mistakes. Everyone is learning.
- 2. Remember What It Felt Like to Be New: Recall how confusing paperwork, transportation, and systems were when you first arrived.
- 3. Stop Turning Every Conversation Into a Competition: Listen and connect without comparing salaries, titles, or possessions.
- 4. Celebrate Success Without Feeling Threatened: Another person's achievement does not reduce your opportunities.
- 5. Help Without Expecting Something in Return: Share knowledge and resources to strengthen the community.
- 6. Be Humble About Your Journey: Long tenure in America does not make someone more important than a newcomer.
- 7. Newcomers Also Have a Role: Do not automatically assume someone speaking English is showing off or rejecting culture.
What Kind of Filipino Community Do We Want?
Do we want newcomers to feel afraid of making mistakes, embarrassed about their accents, or pressured to measure their worth by jobs and cars? Or do we want a community willing to support them? The answer begins with how we treat one another.
My Personal Reflection
Being Filipino in America can mean many different things across generations, languages, and backgrounds. Identity is complex, and differences should never become reasons to look down on others. We can respect one another's distinct journeys without competing.
Final Thoughts: Community Should Feel Like Community
Recognizing challenges means we care enough to improve them. Instead of pulling each other down, we can become the person who helps someone climb. That is the best answer to crab mentality.
Frequently Asked Questions
Filipino crab mentality is a common expression used to describe unhealthy competition, jealousy, comparison, or behavior that attempts to pull another person down when they are succeeding. However, it is not a scientifically established personality trait belonging to Filipinos.
No reliable national statistic establishes what percentage of Filipinos have crab mentality. Researchers have instead studied related concepts such as colonial mentality, internalized oppression, ethnic identity, discrimination, social support, and cultural identity among Filipino Americans.
Psychologists E. J. R. David and Sumie Okazaki developed and tested the Colonial Mentality Scale for Filipino Americans using samples of 292 and 311 participants. Their research found evidence that colonial mentality could be measured as a multidimensional construct and was associated with psychological well-being. A later study involving 410 Filipino Americans examined colonial mentality alongside ethnic identity, acculturation, social support, and mental-health help-seeking.
They may have grown up speaking English, been educated in English, worked in English-speaking environments, lived in America for many years, or simply feel more comfortable using English. Because the Philippines is linguistically diverse, English can also become a common language between Filipinos from different linguistic backgrounds.
No. Someone can speak English most of the time while still strongly identifying with Filipino culture, family traditions, food, music, religion, history, and heritage. Language is only one part of cultural identity.
Absolutely not. It would be unfair and inaccurate to describe an entire population this way. Many Filipinos are supportive, generous, and welcoming toward other Filipinos.
Some newcomers may feel intimidated by differences in language, professional experience, financial status, or familiarity with American culture, especially if conversations become judgmental or overly competitive.
No. Speaking English is not inherently wrong if both people are comfortable. The important issue is respect; language should not be intentionally used to embarrass or make someone feel inferior.
Research has found that colonial mentality is a measurable construct among Filipino Americans and has examined its relationship with ethnic identity, social support, psychological well-being, and mental-health attitudes.
Longtime residents can share information, offer guidance, answer questions respectfully, and avoid making newcomers feel embarrassed about what they do not yet know.
Remember that another person's judgment does not determine your value. Look for supportive people, focus on learning at your own pace, and try not to assume every difference is intentional judgment.
By celebrating other achievements, avoiding unnecessary comparisons, respecting language abilities, helping newcomers, listening instead of judging, and remembering that another person's success does not reduce your opportunities.
A Final Question for Readers
Have you ever experienced a situation where another Filipino made you feel judged, welcomed, supported, or understood after moving to America?
Every Filipino journey is different, but by listening to each other's experiences, we can create a community where success inspires rather than divides.
Research & Sources
The following sources provide the research foundation for this article:
- David, E. J. R., & Okazaki, S. (2006). The Colonial Mentality Scale (CMS) for Filipino Americans: Scale construction and psychological implications. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 53(2), 241–252.
- David, E. J. R., & Nadal, K. L. (2013). The Colonial Context of Filipino American Immigrants' Psychological Experiences. Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology, 19(3), 298–309.
- Tuazon, V. E., Gonzalez, E., Gutierrez, D., & Nelson, L. (2019). Colonial Mentality and Mental Health Help-Seeking of Filipino Americans. Journal of Counseling & Development, 97, 352–363.
- Nadal, K. L. (2020). Colonial Mentality of Filipino Americans. In Filipino American Psychology: A Handbook of Theory, Research, and Clinical Practice.
- [Pew Research Center](https://www.pewresearch.org/). Filipinos in the U.S. Provides demographic, language, immigration, education, and population statistics for Filipino Americans.
Comments
Post a Comment